motz
dimarts, 20. de juliol 2004

don't ask

biologists, neurologists, ... about morality. when it comes to guilt, they don't have an answer. but maybe can tell you more ... i was already on my way home; together with some exhausted philosophers eméritos in the metro.

there is one spanish neurologist i actually want to meet: he has opened up a restaurant and cooks there at night. during the day he counts neurons, i estimate.

... Comment

Guilt: making justice to moral phenomena

During the talk Mariann and I were, Premack said something interesting about science methodology: that you have to make justice to the phenomenon you are interestes in. Premack was talking about emotions and how neurologist do not really make justice to the complexity of the phenomenon.
I believe that biology oriented cognitve scientist do the same with moral phenomena. They like to talk about "selfish genes" and mother's love for their children as rewarded by evolution and so on, but they don't really pay attention to the complexity of moral emotions.
Guilt is a good test on that. Guilt is one of the major moral emotions. To feel guilt you need to be:
a) self -conscious
b) have a representation of yourself as a moral agent. Someone that is aware of the consequences of his/her own actions
c) an internalized moral code that tells you what is right and what is wrong

I am not saying that guilt can not be explained biologically. But I believe that it cannot be devaluated into a simple Darwinian explanation about selfish genes and the release of hormones.

... Link

dilemma

i am self conscious, know can imagine the consequences of my doing and so on and so forth, but still don't feel guilt by smoking blond tobacco. my selfish genes and hormones don't bother about things like that; and they also don't get impressed by - another quote from this curious meeting - that nowadays, in the u of states, 'the prison is the only place where you are allowed to smoke indoor'.

is there a chance, that they didn't know what to say, getting this question in opusdayis land?

... link


... Comment

Online for 8549 days
Last update: 3/11/23 17:00
status
Youre not logged in ... Login
menu
... Home
... Tags


search
calendar
novembre 2024
dg.dl.dt.dc.dj.dv.ds.
12
3456789
10111213141516
17181920212223
24252627282930
novembre
recent updates
human "The mind is what
the brain does." (margaret boden) Mind As Machine. A History...
by motzes (3/11/23 17:00)
when industry looks old i
have no idea how i came here, but i still...
by motzes (13/12/22 21:10)
holography explained it has been
20 years since i met nils abramson and heard about...
by motzes (20/2/22 10:22)
digital dilemma as seen in
the year 2000 . Intellectual Property in the Information Age...
by motzes (28/1/22 8:56)
anti colonial connectivity "... it
was after all, the early days of Intelsat, when having...
by motzes (16/8/21 11:20)
old stories revisited ... ...
makes one search again, along the lines given. brought me...
by motzes (6/7/21 14:27)
history writing gerade
im ohr: ein interview mit verkühlter stimme. aufnahmedatum: 2016.
by motzes (30/3/20 15:42)
Nice Thanks for uploading this.
It's an amazing window on the early history of interactive...
by Kayla (1/3/20 15:51)
gibberjabber interesting, die eingefangenen bots
werden in ihrer wortwahl aggressiv.
by motzes (26/10/19 20:41)
rätsel Daniel Schwenter, Philosophischen und
Mathematischen Erquickstunden, Dritter Theil, 1653 | https://archive.org/details/bub_gb_bGM_AAAAcAAJ
by motzes (22/10/19 19:06)

RSS Feed

Made with Antville
Powered by
helma object publisher